Shifting Euthanasia’s Goalposts: Should NZ create pathways from disability to death?
A proposed amendment to the End of Life Choice Act would extend euthanasia eligibility to people who are not near death.
The current legislation, approved by voters at the 2020 referendum, requires eligible patients to have a terminal illness with a prognosis of six months or less. ACT MP Todd Stephenson’s End of Life Choice Amendment Bill would remove this provision, replacing it with a much broader requirement: that patients suffer from at least one condition that is “advanced, progressive and expected to cause death.”
This means that people with disabilities and long-term illnesses could become eligible despite potentially having years or decades left to live.
Research Manager Maryanne Spurdle examines the risks of removing this key safeguard. Drawing on Canada’s experience, the paper argues that care for vulnerable patients is damaged, and not enhanced, when life-ending options become standard.
The paper raises three central concerns:
- Disability-related discrimination: Patients with disabilities who become eligible and express a wish to die could receive assistance to end their lives, while others expressing the same wish would instead be offered suicide prevention support.
- The challenge for clinicians: Clinicians would face difficult decisions about whether to help eligible patients overcome suicidal thoughts or help them to die.
- Access to care: For patients struggling to access treatment and disability support, euthanasia could become more accessible than the care they need.
Shifting Euthanasia’s Goalposts: Should NZ create pathways from disability to death?
READ THE PAPERLessons from Canada
Canada expanded euthanasia eligibility in 2021 to include patients whose natural deaths are not reasonably foreseeable. Its experience provides an important comparison for New Zealand.
Between January 2023 and December 2024, 67.9% of patients in Ontario who received euthanasia through the expanded pathway reported having at least one disability. That figure was 24.3% for patients whose deaths were reasonably foreseeable. Ontario’s oversight regime has revealed that several patients with disabilities received euthanasia despite needing disability services they could not access. The Canadian experience shows how isolation, inadequate support, and difficulty accessing treatment make end-of-life decisions anything but free and autonomous.
Why the six-month prognosis matters
It is already difficult for physicians to predict when a patient may die. However, without this safeguard, they will be put in the impossible position of predicting how a patient may live. What treatment will be effective? What support will they be able to access? How long will it take for the depression to lift?
The proposed expansion would mark a significant departure from the limits approved by voters in 2020. A post-referendum Curia poll found that 38% of New Zealanders who supported legalisation said they would have voted “no” had they understood that terminally ill patients could qualify even when treatment was available to relieve their suffering. Public support for extending eligibility to people who are not near death cannot be automatically assumed.
Retaining the safeguard and improving care
The paper recommends retaining the six-month prognosis requirement. It also advocates for improving access to specialist palliative care and other treatments and support so that no one repeats the words of a Canadian patient with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). Sathya Kovac wrote her own obituary after choosing euthanasia: “Ultimately it was not a genetic disease that took me out, it was a system. … Vulnerable people need help to survive. I could have had more time if I had more help.”
Expanding euthanasia eligibility means that many vulnerable patients will find it easier to receive assistance to die than help to relieve their suffering.
As the paper concludes, “No patient should find, when they are at their most vulnerable, that death is an option but care is not.”
go back