Jason Heale, Communications Manager at independent think-thank Maxim Institute in Auckland New Zealand

Retribution Nation

By Jason Heale May 17, 2022

A toxic thread has been running through our news lately. Have you noticed?

A CEO deliberately makes disparaging remarks about Nadia Lim. There are calls for his resignation. The share-price of his company plummets. He responds with a two line non-apology.

An atmosphere, not only of division, but of retribution seems to be stalking our country.

Supermarkets cut or freeze their prices. It’s not enough; commentators calling such moves more hype than hope.

Two MPs dispute accounts of a stand-off in a Parliamentary cafe. A Cabinet Minister calls an Opposition member a “useless Māori.”

An atmosphere, not only of division, but of retribution seems to be stalking our country. Of paying others back. Of calling enemies out. Of exacting revenge.

Once you turn someone into a some-what; they are depersonalised and ripe for revenge.

Many of us are not listening; some at the highest levels. Reports surfaced last week of the Human Rights Commissioner trying to get a meeting with the Prime Minister to air his concerns about the traffic light system creating a more divided society. He was made to wait 110 days before the meeting occurred. His take? “My sense is that ‘othering’ is accelerating.”

Once you turn someone into a some-what; they are depersonalised and ripe for revenge.

There are many factors causing this remaking of our land of the long white cloud into a Retribution Nation. Inflation is surging; there is fear about our economic future. Supply chains are broken. Violent crime seems to be rising. People are frightened. Post-COVID, we are still dealing with the ramifications of lockdowns and mandates.

How to respond? It’s not just about us simply trying to be nicer. There are certain active things that we can do in order to come together as a society.

This may seem impossible, given how divided we are told we are, but it has been done before. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission in South Africa showed us the power of open, honest, accountable, and forgiving conversations. In 2019, Maxim Institute brought Professor Pumla Gobodo-Madikizela from that Commission to our country.

We must make a place for such exchanges if we are to come together as a nation. We must demand it of our political and business leaders. And we must practice it ourselves.

Her message was important then, it’s even more urgent now. Professor Gobodo-Madikizela tells of the power of the process of encountering those who have harmed, hurt, and shamed us. She reminds us of a commitment to “staying open in the encounter with the Other’s story and being witness to each other’s stories—stories of pain and stories of shame and guilt.”

We must make a place for such exchanges if we are to come together as a nation. We must demand it of our political and business leaders. And we must practice it ourselves.

Let’s not focus on the retribution, let’s not focus on trying to forget and move on, we have to listen, because listening, as Professor Gobodo-Madikizela notes, is “an important starting point seeking—demanding an ethical response from listeners.” So the next time someone comes to you to complain, debate, or argue, don’t do anything except listen. Really listen. Ask if they think they’ve been heard. Then, in a calm measured manner, make your points. Pause again. Listen again.

For best results, repeat.

go back
Jason Heale, Communications Manager at independent think-thank Maxim Institute in Auckland New Zealand

Maxim Institute is an independent charitable trust that relies on the generous support of families, community groups, trusts, and individuals—without them, we wouldn’t exist.

We’d love to have you join our Community of Supporters. We need people like you to help us continue this work—and to grow it—so we can respond to today’s challenges and opportunities and help create a better future for the next generation.